A film is nothing without a compelling cast. Often times, performances can make or break a film, and believable performances have the ability to set the tone for the world around them. Audiences seek authentic friend groups, undeniable romantic chemistry, and period accurate faces. A lot of work goes into selecting fit performers for a film, and most of that heavy lifting is done by the casting directors.
In “The Liberation,” the cast is a stand out element of the complex, thrilling film. It follows Rita Cooper (Carrie Coon), in the early 1980’s. She’s a closed-off mother of two who works as a bank executive, unable to come to grips with her traumatic past. At the bank one day, she meets the radiant Ricki (Lily James) who invites Rita to join her women’s self-empowerment group. Discovering a new-found freedom, Rita soon comes to depend on Ricki and leaves her family behind to join a cult-like commune in the forest. But when her daughters arrive to rescue her, Rita must choose between the new “spiritual” life she’s found and the loved ones she’s abandoned.
Guy Nattiv’s new psychological thriller, “The Liberation,” is packed full of incredible performances. From powerhouse leads like Chicago veteran Carrie Coon and the enchanting Lily James, to the ensemble of captivating women that make up the fabric of the movie, the film is expertly put together.
Cinema Femme sat down with casting directors Errin Elizabeth Lally, CSA, and Annalese Tilling, CSA, to discuss their career journeys and how they brought the compelling female ensemble to life in “The Liberation.”
How did you get your start in the industry, and how did you get involved in casting?
Errin Elizabeth Lally: We both had different paths. I did it by accident. I graduated from film school and university.
Annalese Tilling: That does not sound accidental.
EEL: Well, I wanted to work in film, but I didn’t know that casting was a job. I wanted to be an AD because being on set was really fun. Then straight out of school, I got a job in casting, and then I was a little bit like Goldilocks, and I still tried every other department. I always ended up coming back to this because I loved it. So, about 15 years into going and leaving and going and leaving, I committed, and that was about 10 years ago. So overall, I’ve been doing it since 1999 with, you know, the odd diversion to a set job just to feel like I’m in the circus.
AT: I just always love any story. Film, TV, especially things that we’re shooting locally. Growing up in and around Vancouver, you see a lot of movies and TV shows being filmed, and I always wanted to be part of it. So I started out in locations and didn’t find that was a super great fit. The really long hours on set…not for me. I moved to the UK for a while and went to university, and then I also worked at the BBC there, which was a dream of mine to work at the BBC, and that was amazing. And then when it came time to move back to Vancouver, I just knew that casting was the department. I just love the creativity of it, the story of it, and the not being on set for 15 hours a day in the rain of it. So I hunted out which casting directors in town were doing the projects I was most excited about and ended up working in casting. That was like, gosh, 15 or 16 years ago. Something like that. I’ve been with Errin, we’ve been casting together for almost –
EEL: Nine years.
AT: Yeah, it’s going to be a decade soon.
What drew you to this project specifically? What about the story made you hop on board?
EEL: I mean, the personal nature of the story for Guy is always something that’s exciting to work with. When someone is that personally involved in the story, you really want to help bring that vision to life in any way you can. So that was exciting. There was nothing that made us not want to do it. I mean, the script’s fantastic.
AT: It’s exciting to see it play out and to think that it’s so based on someone’s experience; their family’s experience. Like, it was an incredible story without that element, but to know it was based in history is amazing.
In general, how does the casting process work? For a film like this with notable names, do you still have auditions? Or do you reach out to performers and have them submit?
EEL: It’s a little bit of all of it. Sometimes we get a project and no one is attached and we’re looking for leads and day players and all the roles. And there’s a different process for both of those types of roles. This project came to us with a number of the leads attached already, which the producers and filmmakers had been working on before it was officially green lit. It was exciting because we knew they were there and the performers that we could help populate the world around them. So we really do both. We do a lot of callouts to agents explaining projects or why projects are great or why we need someone who typically only does a role a certain size that we think would be fantastic in a role that maybe is smaller because the film is so good and the team is so good. Sometimes you do a batch of self-tapes and you find someone you’d never seen before who’s a diamond and you get really excited about that. That just happened to us recently where we saw someone in the room and we were both like, “Where did this gem come from? How have we not met her before?” We live for that. That’s the exciting part. But you definitely do a bit of all of it. You’re releasing breakdowns to agents, you’re brainstorming, and you’re thinking outside the box.
You’re thinking about the best performer. We have the people that we love, and ask “Is there anywhere for them in this world?” Then you also take what’s on the page and you want to treat that like a 100%, you want to give them what they’re looking for, but then you also might be like, “Here’s a random idea.” Sometimes that works and sometimes it doesn’t. So you do all of it.
AT: It’s a lot of personal conversations with managers and agents, just giving really bespoke information about the project and why they’re performance would be such a great fit.
There are a lot of complicated dynamics in this film, especially between the women of the story. What were the starting phases of assembling a group of women that embodied those nuances?
AT: That’s a great question. That was kind of the first thing I think we started working on. We had lots of direction and creative input from Guy, of course. He had a real vision and we needed it to be— we wanted to show a really eclectic, inclusive group of different people from different walks of life, different backgrounds, different ages. It was so crucial to the actual story itself to show that anyone could be seduced by such a group if the circumstances were right. It’s also a lot of mixing and matching different types. We wanted a group of performers who were very open, just because the community itself was a kind of free community, especially more at the beginning. Some people we wanted to be able to have their hair cut, logistical things like that. Maybe some people that were okay with some nudity in some of the scenes where it kind of called for it. Not everybody, but just like a mix and match of faces and personalities.
EEL: There was a big Excel spreadsheet about what performers were willing to shave their heads and okay with nudity. And then it became a mix. It wasn’t that every role had to be both or either. No one had to be. It was just who was open to what for the mixing and matching of it all.
AT: Everybody that was in that group was so talented. Even if the line count wasn’t huge, it doesn’t mean they weren’t super significant part of it. We just had to have really great performers there. That was like, across the board. Also to bear in mind too, some of the conditions. There were a lot of windy roads out in the middle of nowhere and there was some weather and some, you know –
EEL: There was an earthquake. A tsunami –
AT: Yeah, a tsunami warning. So we needed people that were really into the project. You had to be quite passionate about the project too.
EEL: For the record, we moved for the tsunami, but it didn’t actually come.
AT: No, it didn’t. I think it was maybe one foot.
EEL: There was an email that was like, “There’s a tsunami coming,” and then an hour later it was like, “It will be 1 foot high.” It was fine.
They had a few challenges. There was the forest fire. They were shooting about 2 hours outside of Vancouver on an island. We wanted people to be able to be free with the character and be able to play and go toe-to-toe with the powerhouses that they were working with. But also I think the collaboration on set and the process on set was probably very different than a typical feature film that is a giant studio picture or a television network. Everybody, they had the same level of community that is in the film.
AT: They had that in real life.
EEL: They’re on location together, going through these things, working hard. I think we got a batch of people out there that were all open to both sides. To the fictional side of the community and then also the community of the process.
Were there any major challenges you faced when casting for this film?
EEL: Making sure people fit into the time zone, into the ’80s, is always a challenge. You have to look at everybody with a different lens a little bit. Initially, even before you ask them to audition, you have to try and figure out if you think that face would work.
AT: For example, Rita’s father. We needed someone who authentically could be that guy in that era. Ken Kramer was exactly it. There’s a handful of roles like that— Pat, like the face of Pat, so amazing. You don’t get more real than that, you know. I don’t want to give too much away if people haven’t seen it, but yeah, so good. Our whole group, the women on the commune, just like every single one of them are unique and have something that they brought that was different.
I would love to hear a little bit more about building the relationship between Rita and her daughters and how you went about that.
AT: They were actually attached already, so we were very fortunate. How could you not say yes to a project when you’ve got Carrie Coon and Tracy Letts and Bella Ramsey and Odessa Young? That came with it, so that was perfect. That’s something obviously the team had put a lot of thought behind.
EEL: Guy had been working with them over a number of years before the project was even green lit, at different timelines between Carrie and Bella. It had been in his mind for a long time, so I’m sure he’d had plenty of long conversations about their relationships.
Back to you guys, how does the collaborative nature of this process between the two of you work? When did you lean on each other the most?
AT: It’s all day long. With features, we both are very, very engrossed in it and like all consumed. So we’re bouncing ideas and thoughts and questions off each other constantly all day long.
EEL: If one of us is watching a role and gets excited, we tell the other “Stop what you’re doing and come watch this.” Or we’ll go back and we’ll both watch everything and make our shortlists and be excited that like 90% of them are the same.
AT: It’s fun when they’re not the same. Maybe Erin really loves someone, I really love someone, but the other person didn’t shortlist them. But like, guaranteed, if we each have different opinions— and they’re all valid because casting is creative and it’s subjective— but that’s the same with creatives too. I think that’s why it’s really great that there’s 2 brains on everything, because there’s more than one way of doing something. And then multiple creatives will have multiple ideas too.
What’s something that you find is misunderstood by general audiences about your job?
EEL: I think the level of administration. It’s a lot of small details, talking about facial hair or haircuts, that’s the sort of the stuff that comes down to. Sometimes in Vancouver people are doing a couple of shows at the same time, so you’re managing their schedules with other productions. I do think that casting directors are higher profile, so maybe it’s less understood than it used to be. I think that used to be a lot more mysterious, maybe in the ’80s and ’90s. But the internet’s allowed us to all have Instagram accounts and share tips.
AT: There’s so much to it though. Just getting one role cast, there are weeks and weeks and weeks of various steps, various back and forths, various negotiations. You don’t just see an actor and you hire an actor. There’s so much to it.
EEL: It’s also the nuance of all of our relationships with everyone else that works in the industry in Vancouver. We have decades of relationships with the agents in town that’ll hopefully allow us to have a little bit of a shorthand or a bit of trust between all of us about a project like this, which was a small production. It’s not a Marvel movie but obviously we want to provide the highest level of talent and we’re sending them away for 4 weeks to another town. So there’s a lot of conversations on our side to agents and managers explaining why their clients should go do this. At a minimum, it’s for the acting experience of working with Carrie and Bella and Lily and Odessa and everyone over there. But it’s not nothing to pick up your life and go move to a small town for 6 weeks. So those behind-the-scenes conversations take up— that is the job. That is what we do on every project. We do it on small projects and short films and TV. And it’s like, “This is the reason we want this person who you might not have thought of but we thought of.” It’s great when those relationships work out and you get a project like this and you can then give the best of the best to Guy and Jamie and everybody on the project. I don’t know if people understand how much of that is the job.
We don’t just get all the self tapes and go, “We pick that one.” Also, we were in the room a lot with Guy. And watching directors work, I mean, that’s what I love the most is going to an in-person casting session with a director and a writer who’s so involved in the project and watching them hopefully see their vision come to life like they imagined is the best feeling ever.
Cinema Femme, focuses on female and gender-expansive creatives in the industry. What has your experience been like, or what have you learned being women in this role?
AT: It’s interesting. I feel like there’s just so many more female creatives these days that we’re working with. Not always, but I feel like significantly more than even when we started.
EEL: To that point, we still mention it. We just did “Yaga,” the series that’s on AMC in the States and Crave in Canada. Every department head that we would deal with was a woman, and the story is about the powerful women, and we were just like, “Oh my God, guys, we did it!” But, it’s still a note. You’re like, “Oh, look, no men here.”
AT: Specific to this project too, I just want to say Jaime Ray Newman was awesome. She was so supportive, so collaborative, moves things along. She was just a real, real powerhouse and was so wonderful to work with. She produced as well as playing Denise. She was all over it.
EEL: And it was personal for her. She wanted it as great as it could be. You felt very much like we were all there building something that was going to be special.
This film was screened as a part of the 62nd Chicago International Film Festival.